2009-07-13-1B Unscientific America, the gift that keeps on giving

2009-07-13 PZ Myers Pharyngula \Unscientific America http://scienceblogs.com/pharyngula/2009/07/unscientific_america_the_gift.php Unscientific America, the gift that keeps on giving Unscientific America, the gift that keeps on giving  Mooney and Kirshenbaum have been so stung by my criticisms of their book that they have launched a multi-part rebuttal to my review. Here's my reply to their reply. Myers summarizes M&K's replies thusly, and then responds to them:
 * 1) We didn't get personal, and we didn't attack atheism in general!
 * 2) Myers doesn't grasp our point about Pluto!
 * 3) Myers fails to say what the point of the whole book was!
 * 4) Richard Dawkins is no Carl Sagan!

&ldquo;Mooney and Kirshenbaum have been so stung by my criticisms of their book that they have launched a multi-part rebuttal to my review. Here's my reply to their reply.&rdquo;   